How to Use Storytelling to Close More Sales with Neal Foard

From Click to Client Podcast · Episode 86

Why Polished Brand Messaging Falls Flat

Why the most polished version of your message is rarely the one that lands, and how to sound like yourself without losing an ounce of authority.

Episode cover art

Episode 86

Why Polished Brand Messaging Falls Flat, with Heather Sager

Loading the player…

🎧 Apple Podcasts  |  Spotify  |  YouTube

About This Episode

You have worked hard on your message. You have said it out loud enough times that it comes out clean. And it still is not doing what you hoped it would do, which usually leads somewhere frustrating: the assumption that it needs to be even more polished.

In this episode I am talking with Heather Sager, a high performance coach who has been on more than 1,500 stages. For years she communicated on behalf of a company, and she got very good at it. She also describes that version of her voice as awesome, but not fully her. When she started her own business and read her own emails out loud, she could hear it immediately.

We get into why resonance beats getting it right, how she rebuilt her on-camera confidence by reviewing her own footage on repeat, why an era of generated content makes a real voice more valuable, and the question worth asking before you decide how visible your business actually needs you to be.

What You'll Walk Away With

  • Why polished brand messaging can push people away, and what to aim for instead of getting it right
  • How to watch your own videos productively, and the questions that make it worth the discomfort
  • Why personality without substance reads as fluff, and substance without personality reads as a script
  • How to match your visibility to your business model rather than to what everyone else is doing

Questions This Episode Answers

Why does my marketing sound like everyone else?
How do I get comfortable being on camera for my business?
Is being good on video a personality trait or a skill?
How visible do I need to be to grow my business?

"Don't try to attack the fear with more courage. Attack the fear with more skill."

— Heather Sager

Meet Heather Sager

Heather Sager

Heather Sager is a high performance coach for visionary and visible leaders. A former corporate executive turned entrepreneur with more than 1,500 stages under her belt, she helps high achievers show up at the level of their brilliance. She is the host of Hint of Hustle, and when she is not behind the mic she is chasing three young boys, training for a half marathon, or baking sourdough in her cozy log cabin in Bend, Oregon.

Visit Heather's Website
Listen to the Hint of Hustle Podcast
Download the Free Profitable Speaking Guide
Follow on Instagram
Follow on LinkedIn
Follow on YouTube
Follow on Facebook

Connect with Kris Jones

Kris Jones

Kris Jones is the founder of Red Door Stories, a Certified StoryBrand Guide, and a messaging strategist who helps service providers, coaches, and consultants clarify their marketing message so they can attract consistent clients. Her core belief: simplicity is a strategic advantage. Less noise, clearer message, more traction.

Book a Money-Making Messaging Call
Grab the Free StoryBrand Soundbites Toolkit
Follow on Instagram
Subscribe to Kris's YouTube Channel and Learn How to Attract More Clients

📖 Episode transcript

Kris: [00:00:00] Heather Sager, I am so happy to have you here today. This has been a long time coming. I've actually been wanting you on the podcast for quite a long time now. And so I'm just delighted to have you here. you have had such a positive impact on my life. [00:00:15] for our listeners, Heather and I have worked together a handful of times.

Kris: [00:00:19] We did a one-on-one coaching month years ago, oh my gosh, and you really helped me get my first video out on YouTube back in the day. And, also been through [00:00:30] your program, the Signature Talk Accelerator, which was, oh my gosh, deep work, intense, so fun. So you have really helped me show up online and in person to be able to talk about what [00:00:45] I do, to become more visible, to be authentic, to have fun with it, and to not sound like everybody else.

Kris: [00:00:53] Heather, you have been on over 1,500 stages. You are just ... Like, being on stage for you is like [00:01:00] just jumping into a swimming pool, and it just easy, fun, engaging. And, I think we have a lot to learn from you today. So welcome.

Heather: [00:01:09] Oh, thank you so much, and what an intro. And I probably should clarify that jumping into a swimming pool, to me, [00:01:15] sounds horrible.

Heather: [00:01:16] I had a fear, like a massive fear of water, uh, my entire childhood, to the extent where I would sit on the edge of the pool crying while all the kids played. and even to this day as an adult, I c- I identify as a pool-adjacent person. Uh, [00:01:30] for sure. So that is a funny way to, to put my, uh ... I would much rather be on stage in front of thousands than in a swimming pool.

Kris: [00:01:38] That says a lot. That says a lot. Well, I'm really, really happy to have you here, and I, first I really wanna get [00:01:45] into what are you up to lately? Like, how has your business evolved? I know you, you moved. Heather and I both lived in Portland for many years, and I'm still in Portland. Heather has now moved.

Kris: [00:01:56] And so I wanna hear about how that shift, that [00:02:00] move, that new addition to the family, a new baby who, not so new anymore, how has all this kind of informed the new version of your business?

Heather: [00:02:10] Yeah. Okay, I love that we're starting here, and actually talking about this paired with- [00:02:15] our voices. So I actually think it's a really cool parallel.

Heather: [00:02:17] So real quick context, when I lived in Portland, I had one of those high-powered corporate jobs. I had the corner office. I ran a training team for a really successful management firm in medical, in the medical space. And [00:02:30] I definitely was in that, like, let's wear heels all the time, wear the business clothes.

Heather: [00:02:33] I drove the Lexus. I had a really, uh, let's say fancy life. The bougie life is definitely what, what I had, and I loved it. It was all of my hopes and dreams that I had in my 20s, and then when I entered my 30s [00:02:45] and started having children, I started asking big questions. And after having my second kid was when I was like, nope, can't do this anymore, and I started my business, which the whole identity crisis we have after having a child is very exciting for parents.

Heather: [00:02:56] You'll all relate with that. But the, what it comes down to is when I started my, my [00:03:00] business, my online business, I took the role of speaking coach. I had done a ton of public speaking, a ton of being on stage, but it was all masked under another brand. So I always felt like my voice always had to be polished because I wasn't just representing myself as a speaker, I was [00:03:15] also representing this entity.

Heather: [00:03:16] So I was an ambassador on behalf of this company, and I got really good at it, and I had a lot of personality, but I always felt it was, it was definitely polished. It was a version of me that was awesome, but it wasn't fully me. And when I started my business and I started [00:03:30] growing my podcast and my email newsletter, and I remember reading some of my own emails out loud of going, "Wow, this sounds like someone has like a stick up their ass.

Heather: [00:03:38] That's not how I talk to people. It's not how I talk to my friends. I'm like, what would it look like for me to sound more like me? [00:03:45] Mm. And in my content, I started saying things like instead of being nervous of public speaking, I always talked about having your underboobs be sweaty or, like, other really random things.

Heather: [00:03:53] When I would work with business owners and talk about them delivering their first big keynote, I talk about popping their stage cherry, and [00:04:00] all of these things inappropriate, but this is how I talk, right? And I don't talk like grotesquely all the time, but it's all these little unexpected moments because when I do communicate, I have a tendency to be a very polished communicator because I have done so much speaking that I found in teaching [00:04:15] communication that level of polish Was aspirational, but it wasn't very relatable to my clients.

Heather: [00:04:21] That they wanted to be like that, but they didn't see themselves in it because it was a little too advanced for them, if that makes sense.

Kris: [00:04:26] Totally.

Heather: [00:04:27] So I found myself just wanting to do more me. What [00:04:30] would it look like to bring more me? Yeah. And in all these, fast-forward, all these big life questions, business questions, I built this really incredible multiple six-figure speaking coaching business, and then my husband and I decided at the age of 40, let's just make our lives even more [00:04:45] complicated and exciting, and we moved across the state to Central Oregon.

Heather: [00:04:48] And in the same weekend we put our house on the market, we found out we were pregnant with our third child. And, uh, it's now been three years in Bend, three years in Bend, Oregon, and ugh, I [00:05:00] am the same person, but an entirely different person because not only does the way I communicate different, I'm fully myself in how I show up in my, again, my own podcast, my own emails.

Heather: [00:05:08] As you can tell on this interview, I don't hold back. I'm gonna say the weird, inappropriate shit. Yeah. but I also h- I [00:05:15] also have found that in my life too, where I'm no longer working all the time. I now have a toddler at home. I like to bake sourdough. I'm really f- asking myself big questions all the time around, one, what do I want my life to feel like?

Heather: [00:05:25] And two, how do I wanna show up in this phase in my life and in my [00:05:30] business? And I've really found that that question has evolved, and I think it continues to evolve, and I don't think business owners or professionals in general ask that question enough. How do I want to show up? How do I want my work to feel?

Heather: [00:05:41] How do I want to feel as I do that work? And I think that [00:05:45] question, uh, really opens up some really interesting answers and allows us to start thinking about how we communicate in a different way.

Kris: [00:05:51] How do you, how do you wanna feel in your work? I'm curious.

Heather: [00:05:55] Okay, so I've had this mantra for years that I use, and I used to use it on stage back when I was doing a, [00:06:00] a lot of in-person speaking, and I had this idea that, okay, whatever happens on this stage, I have three goals: I wanna make them laugh, I wanna make them cry, and sure as shit, I wanna teach them something that'll change their lives.

Heather: [00:06:10] And I've called this my speaking mantra, but really what it represents for me is I use humor, as you can tell, self-deprecating [00:06:15] humor a lot, unexpected humor in my content. I think learning and growth should be fun, otherwise it's just way too serious. but that second piece is I make people cry, and it's because I share really vulnerable, deep things.

Heather: [00:06:26] I'm not a surface level person. I really like... I wanna feel deeply connected and [00:06:30] feel like the work that I'm doing actually matters. I don't really care about teaching people how to pitch to be on more stages just so they can get more, uh, logos on their website. I care about helping people get their work in front of the people who need to hear it so their lives can change.

Heather: [00:06:42] Like for me, the deep work. I wanna feel like what I'm doing is [00:06:45] meaningful. And then that third piece, I really hate fluffy speakers who just hype people up but don't offer, okay, what do you do right now with that? What's gonna change in your life? How do you take action? So I really think I wanna feel fired up.

Heather: [00:06:56] I wanna feel excited about my life, and I want other people to have that same level of [00:07:00] excitement as they approach whatever challenge that they're facing. So deep work, enthusiasm, excitement, joy. These are all things that I think about all the time.

Kris: [00:07:07] Mm, joy is a big one. I think we can forget that. Like, let me get through this project or let me get through this [00:07:15] month, and then I'll feel the joy, but I'm learning that it's really little moments of micro joy that, that feed the soul.

Kris: [00:07:23] Yeah. Whether it's like, you know- a funny comment or ordering coffee from the [00:07:30] barista and making a joke or cuddling with my kid. Like, the little things really add up

Heather: [00:07:35] It is that, and it's not even... It, it's, the joy is a piece of it, but with so many things, we do that thing where you're saying, "Later, I'll enjoy it.

Heather: [00:07:42] Later, I'll do this. When X, Y, Z happens, then [00:07:45] I'll do whatever." It's, I call this the later lie, and a lot of us, especially coaches, who are really focused on helping people change, we push a lot of things into the future, and most of the time it is our joy. It is the celebration. It's the fun optimization of our [00:08:00] lives, and it's our health.

Heather: [00:08:01] It's how we feel. It's our relationships with our spouse or with our kids. We think that if I can get this one thing off my plate or get through this next season or whatever we have in front of us, we all come up with those BS excuses, but then later we'll get to experience the, the [00:08:15] joy from it or the benefits from it.

Heather: [00:08:16] And I, I think we all know it's bullshit, but we don't call ourselves on it, that we have to start being more aware and responsible for how we feel in the moment, having the hard conversations in the moment so that we can have [00:08:30] better, more, uh, intimate relationships in our lives. We can, choosing to say, "Hey, I gotta clean out my parents' garage because they're selling the childhood home."

Heather: [00:08:39] Okay, that doesn't sound very fun, but how can we turn that into something joyful? How could we turn that into an experience of wow, [00:08:45] like, look at all these memories that are in this thing instead of having to be this heavy thing that you have to deal with? I think every opportunity that you show up for in your business life or your personal life, you get to choose the attitude that you have with it, and that really determines your experience, and I think so many people are offloading that experience to [00:09:00] just chance, and they're just defaulting to negativity, and I don't think that we realize that it's happening.

Heather: [00:09:05] We tend to blame and complain about things that we choose in our own lives. Uh, I think your experience totally changes when you start owning why you're showing up and treat the experience better [00:09:15]

Kris: [00:09:15] Oh my gosh, yeah. I love what you shared about the later lie. I think that, like even naming it is a way to identify it, because it's so believable when you're in the thick of it.

Kris: [00:09:26] I'll just speak for me. I really believe it when I'm like, "No, for [00:09:30] real, once this is done, then..." And, and it's, it is. It's total bullshit, and it's, you know, y- if you kind of look back over the years, I can reflect on the ever presence of that. but I appreciate the name.

Kris: [00:09:44] Yeah, that's [00:09:45] great.

Heather: [00:09:45] I'll add this real quick- Yeah, yeah ... is that right now as we're recording, I don't know when this will air, but the back to school season, e- everyone, it's always so busy. When we get through that, the holiday season, it comes every year, and everybody chooses to all declare it's the busy season, it's miserable.

Heather: [00:09:57] Once we get through the holidays, once we... Like, there... [00:10:00] It's culturally, it's just accepted, and just challenge that if you want to show up better, you have to think not just about your, quote-unquote, "visibility opportunities" when the spotlight's on you. Think about how you show up every single day, what your attitude is, because that's what's [00:10:15] going to trickle over and make your visibility opportunities either be really powerful or just kind of, I hate to use this word because it's totally ChatGPT, but like performative.

Heather: [00:10:23] There is a difference when you're not in congruency in your personal life and your attitude versus your, quote-unquote, "stage life." People can [00:10:30] sense it, and I think people are noticing now that, like more than ever.

Kris: [00:10:33] How do you, how d- how do you, tackle that? Like, how do you make that happen, or how do you help your clients embody that?

Heather: [00:10:41] Yeah. So this... Okay, so we, we mentioned my business has changed a lot over the years. So when it started, I [00:10:45] was doing speaker coaching, and what I was always really deeply passionate about was I wanna help people shine in those onstage moments, but it was less really about nailing a keynote. My thought was, if I can help a client nail a keynote presentation or a signature talk, then they're going to learn how to [00:11:00] become better communicators offstage.

Heather: [00:11:01] So I really focused on those big, stressful moments that people paid attention to with communication, and then it would trickle over. And what I've realized over the last couple years is- While I loved that, I really don't care [00:11:15] about someone giving a keynote. That, to me, it's one moment in time, and I don't work with professional speakers, people who want to build their whole business around speaking on stages.

Heather: [00:11:22] I work with people who are like me. They probably work from a home office, and they have a flexible schedule, and they are damn good at what they do, and they wanna make the [00:11:30] biggest impact possible without it overrunning their lives. They still wanna have the health, they still wanna have the relationships, but they want to be that go-to person.

Heather: [00:11:36] So when I started thinking about that, I'm like, "Why am I not just honing in and talking about communication for experts? Why am I not just claiming and, [00:11:45] and owning this idea that when you show up and communicate, whether it is on a stage, or on a podcast, or on a sales call, or on your own TikTok account, like whenever you show up in the business but also outside of the business, you need to show up at your best because it's the sum of all those moments that actually create your brand.[00:12:00]

Heather: [00:12:00] And so coming back to your question, right, how do you really... how do I help people with that? I moved into what I call high performance coaching, and that's really where I help people become a lot more aware of how they show up both in their business and outside of their business to show up at their best and succeed while maintaining their [00:12:15] relationships and maintaining their overall health.

Heather: [00:12:17] So the first step is helping people become a hell of a lot more aware of how they show up because most of us treat talking like breathing. It's just gonna happen. We do it ev- we've been doing it since we were little kids with our little rambling gibberish. [00:12:30] We talk, but we don't ever really think about the fact that we're talking until there is that high-pressure moment, and then we stress all hell about that moment.

Heather: [00:12:38] So I help my clients start thinking about everyday micro moments when they communicate. How do they become more aware of how they're coming across? How do we [00:12:45] start understanding, okay, if you're not very good at thinking on your feet, you have to understand maybe you're not an external processor. Maybe you're an internal processor, and you have to learn how to externally speak as an internal processor.

Heather: [00:12:57] You gotta learn more about yourself. But [00:13:00] self-awareness is always the first step, and most people are unwilling to look at how they show up right now is because they, they're embarrassed by watching their own videos or role-playing or these things that don't even involve other people. We're so afraid of our own voices and so afraid of [00:13:15] judgment, even of ourselves, that we're unwilling to work on it, so we s- like pull off the Band-Aid and start there.

Kris: [00:13:20] Oh my gosh. That's so good. you had mentioned a while back, I heard you sharing a story about how you [00:13:30] decided, "I'm going to overcome whatever this resistance is, and I'm gonna make that little camera on the top of my monitor my bitch."

Heather: [00:13:40] Yeah,

Kris: [00:13:40] I did

Heather: [00:13:40] say that.

Kris: [00:13:41] And and I, I love that because [00:13:45] it feels, safe, you know?

Kris: [00:13:46] But it's also v- very important forward action to really becoming more comfortable on camera, to really getting to witness w- where are you talking that's working, and in what [00:14:00] ways are you communicating that are not helpful? Or what are the kind of the little habits or ticks that you have when you talk?

Kris: [00:14:06] Tell us about that. Like, what happened for you? What, what happened when you decided to do that, and how did that unfold? How long did it take for you [00:14:15] to get comfortable with this?

Heather: [00:14:16] Yeah. Okay. So this is a really interesting topic, because most people when they think speaking, they think about being on a physical stage, and it's really fascinating.

Heather: [00:14:23] At this stage in my business, a lot of people are coming to me saying, "Oh my gosh, I'm so comfortable on video. I'm so comfortable on [00:14:30] webinars. I'm so comfortable on virtual," but they're terrified of the stage, and it's... Uh, the reason why it's interesting is because for me, seven years ago it was the opposite.

Heather: [00:14:36] People were like, "I'm comfortable on stages, but video is terrifying." So how the pendulum swings in, in, in our world. But so for me, back when I was doing all of my public [00:14:45] speaking, I was showing up on a physical stage of some sort literally every day in my career. So whether I was leading, virtual calls, or we had a training center in Scottsdale, so I was l- literally leading workshops in person all the time.

Heather: [00:14:56] I was on physical stages in Las Vegas. I would fly, I- all over the world [00:15:00] teaching these seminars. So I got really good at being on a physical stage, whether it was 2,000s or in a room of 10 people. I got really good, and I wanna, I wanna clarify this piece, is for me, why I became good is because I got really curious.

Heather: [00:15:13] I started noticing, huh, when do [00:15:15] people lean in? When do they lean out and start playing Candy Crush? When do they engage in the questions that I ask? I would go back, I remember, ugh, this would make me cringe, but before I would give my opening keynote for the certain event, I would always watch the video from the previous time, and I would do it in my [00:15:30] hotel room the night before the event.

Heather: [00:15:31] And I remember one time I was watching this video. I had to wear this... At the time we had to wear polo shirts for this company, and I was wearing this hideous purple polo shirt, uh, in, in this, in this video. But I remember watching it, and I remember thinking like, "What the hell am I doing with my hand?" [00:15:45] And I, I had the clicker in my right hand, but I kept fidgeting with it.

Heather: [00:15:48] And when I set the clicker down, I started fidgeting with my watch, and then I was fidgeting with my necklace, and I'm like, "What is happening?" And when I was... This specific example, I, I think I had been speaking on stages at that company for maybe six months, so I was [00:16:00] really starting to ask questions of how am I coming across right now?

Heather: [00:16:02] And my original question that I was asking was, "What the hell did I say last time?" So I could duplicate it, but then I started realizing, whoa, I was doing these weird things on stage. So I noticed, and then I made changes. I decided to remove all of my jewelry, [00:16:15] and I had to fill, like put that clicker in my hand and be aware of how I was holding it.

Heather: [00:16:19] I bring all this up because when I started my online business, it's hilarious. I had been speaking on stages, and like put me in any scenario, I could, I could deliver world-class- business sermon on a [00:16:30] dime, right? And you can tell I'm not a short-winded person, right? I, I can go. But put me in front of the video camera, and I could not get a sentence out.

Heather: [00:16:38] All of the sudden, my voice would change, and I have, like, a reporter voice. And I'm like- ... "Who is this person talking?" And I [00:16:45] could... Like, every w- sentence was connected with the words and so. It was the world's most run-on sentence there ever was, which I wasn't even aware of at the time. But I could not get my ideas across, and more importantly, I did not like who was showing up to those videos because my [00:17:00] voice got higher.

Heather: [00:17:01] It sounded... It reminded me when I would be in a boardroom with people who had 20 years of experience over me, and I'd s- act, like, weird and awkward, like I was really trying to prove myself. That's how I showed up on video, and I hated it. And so when I started... There's my and connecting everything together.

Heather: [00:17:14] You get a [00:17:15] little sample there. Uh, but when I started doing video, I'm like, "I, I have to get over this fear." And well, that's when I said, "I'm gonna make this camera my bitch." So I said, "What did I do to get more comfortable, and not just comfortable, but really damn good on stages?" I practiced every [00:17:30] single day.

Heather: [00:17:31] And not only did I practice, I went back and watched the game tapes. So this was back in 2018, where Facebook Live, I would say, was at its peak. I went live every week on Facebook. I had my own little show. I created a little intro for it, a little title. I would go live and [00:17:45] talk, uh, on a topic, and then what I did is I...

Heather: [00:17:48] This is back when captions were s- terrible, and you would... Uh, it was a really complicated process how to turn on cap- captions, but they were, they were not accurate. So I would go through and hand key and fix all of the captions- Wow ... of the [00:18:00] videos. And it was through doing that, which side note, if y'all are listening going, "Oh, there's so much more efficient ways to do that," that wasn't the point.

Heather: [00:18:06] I wasn't trying to be efficient. What I wanted to do was literally painstakingly hear and see everything I did in those videos, [00:18:15] and I hated every second of it. And I was like, "Oh man, why is everything a question mark? Why is everything running together? Why am I saying 'and so' and s- so much? Why are my hands doing that?

Heather: [00:18:22] Like, what's up with my left eyebrow?" Like, all these stupid things. But it wasn't until I was able to stare it in the eye and have such an [00:18:30] annoyingly pissed off nature of level of awareness that I then could create change the next time I recorded. The next time I record it, I'm like, "I'm gonna pause for a second and breathe instead of saying so many filler words.

Heather: [00:18:42] I'm going to look at the camera instead of my [00:18:45] face on the reflection." Like in real time that next week I can make another change, and I just think so many people are unwilling to do these little details I'm talking about here because right now we're in an era where everybody wants to spend less time doing their work.

Heather: [00:18:59] We want [00:19:00] more efficiency, and let me just tell y'all this, efficiency does not create skills. In fact, it shortcuts them, and I think it degrades skills. So if there are areas in your business where you need to have world-class skills, stop outsourcing it. Stop trying to [00:19:15] shortcut it, and do the painstakingly freaking annoying work of building the skill, which is gonna suck, but hot damn can I tell you I sure know how to make the camera my bitch now.

Heather: [00:19:24] I mean, I've been staring at the little black hole. Kris, your face is over on my left. I haven't looked at you once during this entire probably very long TED [00:19:30] Talk I just made. I know how to look at that camera and maintain a level of charisma, eye contact, body language, facial expressions, my voice cadence.

Heather: [00:19:38] Sure, I used some filler words, but we can talk about that in a minute. there's actually a reason I use those now. Uh, anyways, all this to be said, you, you gotta [00:19:45] figure out what's the skill you're trying to learn and embrace the suckiness of it.

Kris: [00:19:49] Yeah. Wow. How long did it take you until you reached a point where you were like, "This is so much better.

Kris: [00:19:57] I'm not... It's not torture for me to watch myself on camera [00:20:00] anymore"?

Heather: [00:20:03] Okay, random. This is very random. Here's how I'm gonna answer your question. The other day I was looking at my toddler, and I don't know if you remember this with your young kids, you know how, like, little kids don't have kneecaps?

Kris: [00:20:13] Yeah.

Heather: [00:20:13] It's very random.

Kris: [00:20:14] Yeah. [00:20:15]

Heather: [00:20:15] I looked at my little one, he's almost three, and he doesn't have kneecaps, and I realized, when did my older two c- kids, who are eight and 11, when the hell did they get kneecaps?

Heather: [00:20:23] I have no idea. It's just one day they had kneecaps. And I don't know when it happened. And that's what happened for me with [00:20:30] video. Yeah. I have no idea when it happened, and what I will tell you is it probably...

Heather: [00:20:37] My confidence and skills probably came in stages, where when I look back, even at my videos... Actually, if [00:20:45] you type in Heather Saker hand gestures into YouTube, you will see a video I probably did maybe six months into me practicing video, and at the time, I'm like, "This is so much better." I now look at it and I'm like, "That is so terrible."

Heather: [00:20:57] You can actually see my voice is [00:21:00] much higher. I look like I'm trying to be a certain persona on camera. Like, how I talk today is drastically different than how I- Mm-hmm ... talked six, seven years ago. Mm-hmm. But at the time, I was like, "Oh, this is so much better." I couldn't even get a sentence out six months prior.

Heather: [00:21:13] So I, I was able to [00:21:15] start going from... What I didn't share with you is my first month of doing this, I did, definitely did not go live on Facebook. It was just me and my webcam saved on my remote desktop. Like, I didn't put it anywhere. It was just me and the camera. It was just private, and it was very cringey, very awkward.

Heather: [00:21:28] So, but I think I started [00:21:30] going live within 90 days, and then from that, I sort of started posting to YouTube, and then from there, I created my podcast. And then now it's been, I don't know, six, seven years since I released my podcast. Oh

Kris: [00:21:39] my gosh. And yeah. And at what point, at what point in that journey were you like, "I'm showing up [00:21:45] very polished, but this is not me"?

Kris: [00:21:47] And what was w- what was the process of really kind of unlearning that polishedness? 'Cause I lo- like, the way you show up on your podcast is so refreshing. I [00:22:00] love the F-bombs, whatever, like, whatever it takes. Like you just... There's no filter, and I think, like, that type of realness is, I think people are really hungry for it.

Kris: [00:22:10] Yeah. And I think it just feels good, and it's, and [00:22:15] it's way more fun. so how did you kind of... How did you undo that? 'Cause I would say, like- I'm similar in that I can show up, I can be polished. I think people think of me as maybe [00:22:30] more polished or maybe more put together. But if you really know me, I'm very much not.

Kris: [00:22:36] Like, really, like, I, yeah. And so I'm just curious, like, how did you unlearn You must unlearn what you have learned. Yes. How [00:22:45] did you do

Heather: [00:22:45] it? So I think it's a, a matter of constantly asking yourself the question around what are my goals, uh, who am I talking to, and how can I show up as the best version of myself today?

Heather: [00:22:54] And I know that sounds kind of cheesy, but that it wasn't... It was less of how do I sound less [00:23:00] polished, and more of how can I resonate more with my ideal client. Right. And so this I actually wanna point out real quick. One of the things that's really fascinating, when people would come to me for the Signature Talk Accelerator, and they really wanted to nail down their messaging.

Heather: [00:23:12] Yeah. They knew they were experts, but they were suffering from the curse of the expert, [00:23:15] which means they could talk about their stuff in circles, but other people didn't quite get it. Right. Or they'd politely nod their head, but they really weren't invested. They didn't understand why do I need this now, why me, why you, all these things.

Heather: [00:23:24] And what would happen is people would come to me, and they were so focused on wanting to get their [00:23:30] message right. They're like, "Give me the structure so that I say it in the right way so that people will buy." Like, that's essentially what people were saying without saying it. Yeah. And I, over the years I have gotten much better at not trying to be like a nice way to put [00:23:45] it.

Heather: [00:23:45] I would just flat out tell my clients, "Stop that shit," right? You're... We're not here to get it right. Nobody wants right. People want to resonate with what you're saying, so we're going for resonation over right here, okay? So when I started realizing that of [00:24:00] myself, I would think about my content, right? So l- let's take my weekly newsletter as an example.

Heather: [00:24:03] I would write an email, and what would happen is as I was writing my email, I would then read it out loud. And I was reading out loud, anywhere where it sounded a little clunky, I, I could feel the friction in me saying, [00:24:15] "This is not how I would say it." So I would move to, well, how would I actually say it?

Heather: [00:24:19] And one of the exercises I know you and I have done before, uh, but I would do to myself, is I would tell my clients, "How would you say this if you were three margaritas deep?" And that right there is like the opener for so many people. They [00:24:30] would say it so much simpler, and that's how I helped a lot of people come up with their core message and better ways to explain their shit.

Heather: [00:24:35] But I started doing that on myself, is, well, how would I actually say it? And then I realized that's way more interesting. I don't, I don't want to read about, I don't know, generic things around [00:24:45] messaging. Uh, be more aligned. Uh, live a better li- like j- I don't wanna read that stuff, and nobody else does either.

Heather: [00:24:50] When you use language that's unexpected, that's, authentic, that just, I don't know, it's enjoyable to read, again, bringing a joy to what you're doing, I think when we start thinking about [00:25:00] that, it starts... We start asking the questions, how would I communicate this like a real person to another real person versus as an entity trying to position myself as the expert.

Heather: [00:25:08] So long, very long-winded, as we learned here- Mm-hmm ... uh, way to say I don't know that I ever was like let me remove the polish. I [00:25:15] think I just decided- I'm going to stop trying to position myself as the first impression, I don't know, polished version, and just go, "You know what? Maybe I'm not gonna build the fricking multi-million dollar company if I [00:25:30] built myself as this like look at me in my fancy heels and my fancy cars," which by the way, I got rid of all of those things when I moved to Bend.

Heather: [00:25:35] Uh, what if I was the bitch in the kitchen with the sourdough, uh, talking over B-roll while my kids are going crazy in the background, but talking about my first presentation and where I got it wrong and where you can learn from that? [00:25:45] Like- Mm ... what if I just shared my life more authentically? And here's the key that I want you all to hear.

Heather: [00:25:50] Yes, I'm real. Yes, I say these really inappropriate things that we have just, uh, established in today's episode. But the content and what I teach is [00:26:00] really freaking good. I have simple systems. I have frameworks that I have named, AKA the later lie, and some other things we'll get into, right? I have really strong substance, and I think this is where people really like muck it up, is they try to be too friendly and [00:26:15] "Hey, girl" and casual, but then they lack the substance that translates to other people.

Heather: [00:26:20] So you have to come across as wicked freaking smart, and that for me, I'm wicked freaking smart. I'm really good at taking complex ideas and making them simple, uh, making them pedestrian, if you will, so [00:26:30] other people can get it. But I don't talk like a snuffy snooty person. I talk like a real person, and the juxtaposition of those two things is my brand.

Heather: [00:26:37] It's why it works so well. But if you have really basic content and you're just regu- regurgitating basic shit that people already [00:26:45] know, and you talk like a basic bitch like me, those two things together are not gonna position you as the expert. So I wanna make sure that I'm not confusing being casual or plainspoken with my language and a little weird.

Heather: [00:26:56] You have to pair that with really good [00:27:00] content. And the cool part is, if you're listening to this show, if you're really good at what you do, I wonder, I just wonder how much you dilute what you do because you generalize it and you try to make it reach so many people that you're actually diluting your work, and therefore people don't see it as good as it [00:27:15] actually is

Kris: [00:27:15] Mm.

Kris: [00:27:17] Mic drop.

Heather: [00:27:17] Yeah.

Kris: [00:27:19] You talked about walking, walk the talk, talk the walk. What does that mean? Tell, tell us what's been ruminating in your brain about, around

Heather: [00:27:28] that. Okay. So I was sharing a bit of this before. I [00:27:30] haven't shared this publicly, but I have had a goal of wanting to write a book, like, my entire career.

Heather: [00:27:34] This has always been on my list of I wanna run a marathon and I wanna write a book, these two things. I'm working on the marathon right now. I have registered for a half-marathon in April, get my, get my post-baby ass back in gear. But the book piece, I've [00:27:45] always asked the question, what do I wanna write a book on?

Heather: [00:27:47] And going back to what we talked about, I didn't really want my book to be about how to deliver a great stage talk. Like, I knew that was a piece of it, but it wasn't the thing. And what's really come up for me over the last two years is- I've been playing with this idea [00:28:00] of so many of the people that I work with at the executive level, I work with a lot of founders and executives, and where they struggle is, yes, how they communicate, but they're struggling with things like boundaries.

Heather: [00:28:10] They're struggling with the, uh, they're overworking in the office. They're- they have so many [00:28:15] emails, but they tell their teams, like, "Take the weekend. Don't email at night," but they're emailing at night. And a lot of executives, uh, they're really good at what they do, but they aren't walking the right talk, so we need to work on how do you actually show up as the best version of yourself?

Heather: [00:28:28] How do you actually walk that talk and not just [00:28:30] say it? But on the other end, I think equally so, there are so many really strong leaders and really strong experts who over the years have a really good walk. They have the street cred. They have the experience. They know what they're doing, but they have relied on their [00:28:45] work speaking for itself, relied on word of mouth and referrals, and I get that because I'm a huge relationship person.

Heather: [00:28:50] In fact, I wrote a whole email about it this morning around how all my speaking opportunities are from relationships and referrals. But there comes a point where you have to be able to communicate, one, what it is that [00:29:00] you do, two, why people should care, and three, how to get people to, like, engage in your work, right?

Heather: [00:29:05] You have to be able to talk the walk. You can't just be good at what you do. And I think these two things, we're headed into an era that they're going to be more important now than ever. I think we have to, we have to [00:29:15] have a better walk because with the h- introduction of AI over the last few years and the mainstreaming of it, I don't know if that's a word, but we're gonna make it, but so many people using it to create content, to create efficiencies in their business, I think people are really looking for those who have [00:29:30] actually walked in the shoes that the person's wanting to learn from, right?

Heather: [00:29:34] I think a lot of people are getting good at messaging and marketing from AI, but there's no substance around it. So I think the people who know how to walk the talk, they're really going to come out, but only if they can talk their [00:29:45] walk, meaning- Mm ... they can articulate their value. They can speak in a way that gets other people not just to listen, but it holds that attention, right?

Heather: [00:29:53] I think, I don't know if you've been following online, there's a lot of people who are getting really good at writing hooks. You can get a video. You can [00:30:00] get someone to listen, but have you ex- had that experience where you start listening to someone's video and then realize that, oh my gosh, this entire thing is a ChatGPT script.

Heather: [00:30:06] I'm out. Yeah. Right? But when you have someone who is messy, and maybe it had a good book, maybe it didn't, but they start talking, and you just resonate, and you like that person, right? There's substance there, yes, as [00:30:15] we determined that has to happen, but there's something about the way that they communicate that you're like, "Hot damn, I really resonate with this person."

Heather: [00:30:21] I think those are the people who are going to shine, and I don't think this is a personality trait. I think this is a skill that so many people could master. They're just not noticing they [00:30:30] need to.

Kris: [00:30:30] How would one go about mastering that skill?

Heather: [00:30:33] Yeah. Okay, well, it goes back to what we said before, awareness.

Heather: [00:30:35] So my question for all of you is when was the last time you watched one of your own videos? And watched it, now let me clarify, watched it from a productive point of view. [00:30:45] And what I mean by that, it's too many times my clients will watch their videos and all they focus on are the things that they cannot change.

Heather: [00:30:51] Case example for me, the joke I always make, why is my left, left eyebrow so overactive, but for the life of me I cannot raise my right eyebrow? That, I've tried it. There's nothing changeable about that. For some [00:31:00] reason, the muscles in my face, the right eyebrow does not work on its own. Like, I... I'm doing it right now.

Heather: [00:31:04] For those on audio, it looks really weird. Right? That is not a productive thing to focus on. For me to be like, "Oh, here's another one I totally criticize myself about," my upper lip doesn't move when I talk. I have to consciously think about smiling [00:31:15] to show my teeth, otherwise when I talk it's just my bottom lip showing my bottom teeth, which is highly unattractive, but I can't do anything about it unless I focus and smile, but if I smile the time, that's weird.

Heather: [00:31:22] Okay, I'm using these really weird examples on myself to show you this is what most people focus on, is why do I look weird? Why do I sound [00:31:30] weird? Things that are, like, not really changeable. Or another one, this was me postpartum, I hated how I looked on camera because I had gained so much weight during pregnancy, and I was bloated, and my skin was not great, and I didn't have time to get my hair done, and my grays were showing, and ugh.

Heather: [00:31:44] [00:31:45] So many women especially, because of their weight or because of their feeling, they just nitpick the shit out of themselves on camera. My question for you is, is it helpful to focus your energy on those pieces, or is it a hindrance to you getting your message out? So when we, we have to focus on [00:32:00] productive when we, when we watch our videos.

Heather: [00:32:02] So how do we be more productive? We ask questions, can we change it, right? Okay, how can I say that better? Okay, how can I hold better eye contact? Ooh, I'm looking at the screen, not on there. Where do I look? Let me open up my camera and test it and see if it works. [00:32:15] Holy crap, I talk really fast. Is that a bad thing?

Heather: [00:32:17] Not always a bad thing. As you notice, I talk really fast. I think people's brains move fast. Like, don't talk slow. It's boring. We all wanna put things in 2X speed. Like, think about how do you phrase things better? Did it take you forever to get to your point? The question [00:32:30] is, are you gonna talk about this topic again?

Heather: [00:32:31] Yes? Okay, then it's worth practicing it and saying, "What was my point? And next time can I start at the point and then back it up?" Versus ramble my way to the point just to figure out what I'm saying. You see what I'm getting at here? Mm-hmm. Is focus on watching your own shit, and then asking [00:32:45] productive questions that are changeable and practicable, and then improve on the next one.

Heather: [00:32:49] And when I say the next one, don't wait a week. Do it again that day or the next day. Like, put in the reps. These things can be changeable very, very quickly. Uh, case in point, back when I was on stage and my hand gestures were super weird, [00:33:00] I literally used to walk around my office. Back, I would take all of my phone calls...

Heather: [00:33:04] Um, I have hearing aids, so I stream phone calls in my hearing aids I would take everything standing up, and it wasn't a video call, it was audio calls, but I would walk around my office, moving my [00:33:15] hands around like I was speaking on a stage to start training my brain how should my hands move when I speak.

Heather: [00:33:21] Because here's, here's what's interesting. All of y'all think that this practice stuff, like, I don't know. I don't know what we're trying to do with it, but what I want you to think about, let me use the analogy of a [00:33:30] sports, a sports person. A sports person. Um, I'm watching Ted Lasso right now, so it's about soccer.

Heather: [00:33:37] Yeah. Athletes, right? When they do practice, so on game day, on game day they just do what they've been trained to do. The coach isn't [00:33:45] calling, like telling the striker when to go or who to pass to. The coach's job is during practice. On the game, your just natural instincts come out, so training is into work.

Heather: [00:33:52] This, this is the same thing with speaking. You can't try a hand gesture tick, uh, trick when you're recording a video live. You can't think about how do I use [00:34:00] better, sh- perspective shifting psychology in my keynote? It's not, you're not gonna remember to do it, and you're gonna fumble the punchline of a joke.

Heather: [00:34:07] Or if you're trying to memorize your script, you're gonna screw it up. You have to practice outside of the actual game so that when you do show up, it's [00:34:15] just ingrained. So for me, the hand gestures. I practiced all the time so when I got on stage, the last thing I was thinking about was what I was doing with my hands.

Heather: [00:34:22] Mm-hmm. I think this is what we need to ingrain in our brains more. Where are we focused? How are we showing up? What can we fix? And then how can we practice to make it second nature? [00:34:30]

Kris: [00:34:30] Hmm. Yeah, and you could even have, you know, Claude or ChatGPT uh, come up with prompts for you to tackle every day, and then you just answer those questions in five, 10 minutes every day, and-

Heather: [00:34:42] Yeah

Kris: [00:34:42] by the end of a month, you're in a totally different [00:34:45] place.

Heather: [00:34:45] Yep. Yeah. You can think about it. Put Claude... I haven't done this before. I have a different exercise I do with clients, but you can put into Claude and say, "Hey, you're, uh, my PR media coach," right? Mm-hmm. And make sure you're very clear, right? You don't want it to give you any scripts or any talking points.

Heather: [00:34:57] This is very important that you come up with these things on your own, [00:35:00] otherwise you're gonna get into reciting mode, and reciting mode never sounds authentic. I'm gonna be honest with all of you. None of y'all are Hollywood actors- No ... like A-list actors that are, like, really good, like, believable characters.

Heather: [00:35:10] You're not Ted Lasso here, okay? So when y'all recite scripts, my [00:35:15] brain, and most people's brains, tune out. Even though it might be the right words, what did we say earlier? It's not about getting it right, it's about resonating. Right. And the delivery of a recited script, it's like nails on a chalkboard right now.

Heather: [00:35:26] You can

Kris: [00:35:26] feel it. So

Heather: [00:35:26] please stop

Kris: [00:35:26] doing it. You can feel it. It doesn't matter how [00:35:30] well you know the content, you really can feel it on the other end. one of the things that I do a lot with friends is Marco Polo. Yeah. And Marco Polo is a really great app. Number one, it's a great way to just stay connected with other people, but it [00:35:45] also forces you to look at your own self when you're talking to friends.

Kris: [00:35:48] So I feel like that has been a really good tool for me just to- three margaritas in kind of vibe with friends, but having to [00:36:00] watch myself deliver information.

Heather: [00:36:01] Yeah, I love it. I think you and I may have used Marco Polo early. That was what I used in my business early on with all of my clients, I used Marco Polo.

Heather: [00:36:07] I forgot about that. But it was back when Marco Polo was free, so you could watch things in, like, 2X speed, and they made it paid, so I've since moved to Voxer for that. [00:36:15] But that, I forgot about that. That video piece of everyday conversations, what's fascinating, uh, it... You start off by really thinking about what you look like, and then within a week you're, like...

Heather: [00:36:25] I don't know, it's looking up your nose while you're talking- ... and brushing your teeth or whatever, right? You, you get over it pretty quickly. Right. But yeah, [00:36:30] if there's a, if there's a sting of how you look on camera, you just need to normalize it by, by doing it as much as possible. I find Instagram Stories is a really great way to get over this, because they disappear in 24 hours.

Heather: [00:36:42] Now, the big asterisk to this is a lot of [00:36:45] people hear that and they're like, "Ooh, okay, let me focus on making really good Instagram stories." I don't want you to focus on trying to create effective content that converts or trying to have a strategy around it. The strategy is to not pee your pants when you create video, right?

Heather: [00:36:57] That's like step number one. If you're fearful of it or you're uncomfortable with it [00:37:00] or you sound like that really polished, stick-up-your-ass, no offense, but that's probably not resonating with your clients right now, right? So thinking about, how can I show up more authentically with good substance?

Heather: [00:37:11] Remember that pairing there. How could I do that? And don't [00:37:15] worry about whether or not your Instagram stories are getting the replies or the views, or don't look at any metrics. You're doing this for you. You're not doing it for anybody else but for you in the beginning so that you can build that habit and that comfort and that level of awareness, so then you can get to the good part where you start optimizing it and making it better.

Kris: [00:37:29] Oh, I love [00:37:30] it. I love it. This has been packed with so much incredible information, Heather. Thank you. I want to wrap up today with two questions. Number one, I really wanna hear, like, what's the difference for a coach or a consultant that just does not wanna be [00:37:45] visible? Like, what do you do in that case?

Kris: [00:37:47] Like, are they able to effectively grow, reach the right people, versus somebody who's willing to- Take the leap, get uncomfortable, get more visible, whether it's on podcasts or on [00:38:00] actual stages. Like, what's the path for the both of those people?

Heather: [00:38:04] Okay, I love that you asked this question, because I think so often we see so many examples of really visible people, and we think, "Oh, that's what I have to do too."

Heather: [00:38:10] And I'll use the example I sent in my newsletter this morning, where I was talking about relationships. I know a lot [00:38:15] of people in my business world that really love finding all the events going on in the industry, and then completing the speaker applications so they can be in the summit, they can be at the event.

Heather: [00:38:24] Like, they love just getting themselves out there. Weird thing for me, uh, I hate, with my [00:38:30] whole heart, any kind of form. I will not fill it out. In fact, that... I don't, fill it out. My personal assistant does it. But to take it a step further, I do not fill out speaker forms. So if someone, let's even say, someone invites me on their summit, and then sends me, "Here's my speaker application," I politely say, "No, thank you."

Heather: [00:38:43] Like, I will speak, but I will [00:38:45] not be filling out your form. Like, I don't s- fill out forms. And I used to think this was an asshole admission, but I just... I don't have to. I don't, I don't have to do that. I get plenty of speaking opportunities, and if somebody has an issue with that, I'm not gonna speak at their event.

Heather: [00:38:55] I bring this up because we're conditioned to do things a certain [00:39:00] way. In order to find opportunities, you have to be willing to pitch, you have to have your media kit. Like, my me- I still don't have a speaker page, y'all. Let me just tell... I don't have a speaker page, and I have made multiple six figures from speaking, like in speaking fees, okay?

Heather: [00:39:13] You don't have to do [00:39:15] what anyone tells you you have to do. What you have to figure out is what are my goals, what are my strengths, and what's the strategy to get there? Now, if you make up the strategy from scratch, just know that who knows if it's gonna work, right? But you can find other people to model.

Heather: [00:39:27] So let me just tell you this. There are a bajillion [00:39:30] examples of people who are super visible that do super well. There are also a lot of examples that you probably don't see of people who are not very visible and still do very, very well. The question that I would be asking is what is the business model?

Heather: [00:39:43] And this is what I ask with all of my clients. [00:39:45] If you have a business model where you're a coach, and you work one-on-one with people, you do not need to go on Instagram and build this huge-ass audience, because you only work with a handful of people every month. You just don't need the marketing and the brand to back up [00:40:00] w- your business model.

Heather: [00:40:01] Now, if you're trying to do a business model where you're selling low-ticket digital offers, well, yeah, you're gonna need the audience, but even then, you could do paid ads. There's always a different approach. My question for you would be are you saying, "I don't wanna be visible," because you're scared of it?

Heather: [00:40:14] Okay? That... [00:40:15] Be aware of it. Are you willing to get over that fear? But the bigger question is, is the work that you're doing, do more people need to hear it? And do you want to be the person to share your story to help them hear it? And if there is that deep desire there that you [00:40:30] wanna help more people, don't try to attack the fear with more courage.

Heather: [00:40:33] Attack the fear with more skill. Okay? Ooh, that sounded good, didn't it? Right?

Kris: [00:40:37] Ooh, duh.

Heather: [00:40:38] But that, like, you don't have to muster up the courage, you just have to get, get skill going. So figuring out where can I grow this skill, where can I get the practice, [00:40:45] as we talked about today, even if it's just with yourself.

Heather: [00:40:47] In the beginning, it's all about getting more comfortable for you to show up, and then you can make it good. So I don't know, long-winded way, you could build your business however you wanna build your business, but don't make that decision out of fear. Think about the best version of [00:41:00] you and the business that you wanna have five years from now.

Heather: [00:41:03] How does she show up? How does he treat content? How does he look at visibility? Is it strategic? Is it a necessary evil? Is it a, "Ugh, I hate it. It's not worth its time"? Remember earlier when [00:41:15] I said the energy and attitude you bring to things determines your success in all facets of your life? This is one of those examples.

Heather: [00:41:21] So if you have a shitty attitude around visibility, you're gonna get shitty results and have a shitty experience with it. If you have a intimidated attitude around visibility, [00:41:30] ask yourself better questions, and, uh, connect it to your bigger vision around what you're trying to create, and you'll find you're a hell of a lot more willing to get uncomfortable to make it happen.

Kris: [00:41:38] Mm. Wow. Just a moment to just let that all soak in. Heather, [00:41:45] thank you for being here today. Tell us how we can get more of you and find you and potentially work with you.

Heather: [00:41:52] Yeah, I'd love that. Thank you for giving me the opportunity to share. So couple things. If you're listening to the podcast right now, you're most likely a podcaster and like me, you like to have things in your ears.

Heather: [00:41:59] And [00:42:00] if you love the idea of getting fired up and the weird way that I communicated today, you're like, "Hell yeah, I wanna learn business and how to show up better," uh, the best place to go is my podcast. It's called Hint of Hustle with Heather Sager, so we can link that here. Um, that last piece when you talked about visibility, a lot of people, they get stuck on [00:42:15] visibility because they've had experiences where they've done a lot of work to show up, but it's not had a lot of payoff.

Heather: [00:42:20] And what I find is a lot of business owners don't know how to get a return on that visibility. And so if that's a challenge for you, whether you're showing up for podcast interviews or you're showing up for your own [00:42:30] stages, or you wanna get more into guest speaking but you just don't really know if it's worth your time, you can check out...

Heather: [00:42:35] I have a free guide around speaking and how to get a better ROI. One of those places is how to get paid, but there are three other types of currencies that you can generate a kickback on. Uh, if you wanna grab that, you can head on [00:42:45] over to heatherSager.com/guide, and I'll teach you my strategy for speaking, how you get a return, and I'll give you some specific tactics that you can use to milk more juice from those speaking opportunities.

Kris: [00:42:54] Incredible. Thank you so much. We'll have to do it again.

Heather: [00:42:57] You're welcome.

Your clients are sizing you up long before you make an offer.

How you present yourself and what you say both send a signal. And most business owners aren't being intentional about it.

In the newest episode of From Click to Client, I'm talking with Neal Foard, an advertising guru who's worked with some of the biggest brands in the world.


Neal has spent his career studying what actually moves people to trust, buy, and come back.


Here's a little of what we cover in this episode:


  • The story you tell matters more than how polished your delivery is.
  • The trick to sounding more authentic and less rehearsed.
  • What a troll doll can teach you about the ROI of a kind gesture


If your message feels right but clients aren't responding, this episode will show you why.


Listen to the full story here.

How to Use Storytelling to Close More Sales with Neal Foard

Welcome to from Click to Client, where we transform a confusing message into a clear, compelling story that sells. I'm your host, Kris Jones, StoryBrand marketing expert. I'm here to help you attract more dream clients with the power of story.

Kris: Welcome to the podcast, Neal.

Neill: Thank you, Kris.

Kris: Yeah.

Neill: Appreciate it.

Kris: Fellow storyteller, guru, and just an overall delight of a human being.

Neal, tell us a little bit about yourself.

Neill: Well, like you, I came from the propaganda business. I spent 30 plus years trying to create persuasive messages on behalf of brands and, trying to create experiences when I was in the experiential marketing part of that. And over the course of that, that long career, I discovered that maybe the most, excuse me, maybe the most cool tool that you walk away with.

Is a sense of how to be persuasive as a person. And if, if I could offer you any one of four superpowers, for [00:01:00] example, super strength or the power of invisibility, or the ability to jump into the air and fly it fast as a jet, or I gave you the ability to change people's minds, that's the one that is the most powerful.

Because with the power, with the ability to change people's minds, you can get anything you want. Anything that you could get by super strength, you can easily get by persuasiveness. It's since the invention of language, the ability to change people's minds has been the most potent and powerful way to take advantage.

I'm so sorry. I made the mistake of eating an almond before we went on, and now it is decided to establish base camp somewhere right about here.

Kris: It's resurrected.

Neill: Yeah. Anyway, but to, to complete the picture. So it, it wasn't, it wasn't so much learning to be persuasive by crafting persuasive messages for clients.

It was in the act of trying to sell the ideas to the clients. That's when you really found out whether you had any chops as a, you know, as, as [00:02:00] a Bengali, as the ability to sell someone something. When, and as you would know, only too well, Kris, people, you can't persuade somebody to buy something when they don't want to buy it.

If they don't want to buy it. Any excuse will do. If they wanna buy it, any reason will suffice. You know, the, the, so. The, the art of persuasion, and this goes right back to Dale Carnegie, 1933. I think the art of persuasion has everything to do with trying to make people feel good about you. And, you know, that's why I put this above my desk life as a team sport, that the, the more you see each other as friends and colleagues and not competitors, the more that you see your fellow human being as somebody who's experiencing the thing, same thing you're experiencing at the same time.

And that you should have empathy and compassion for them, not fear and distrust. The more you do that, the more you will capitalize on what makes us powerful as a species. Cooperation. Cooperation is where we get our power. Just imagine, Kris, I want [00:03:00] you to, you know, you and I are cave, caveman, and cavewoman on the African plane hundreds of thousands of years ago, and we are being approached by hyenas.

Or a pride of lions. Now, who do you think is more frightened? Us of the hyenas or 50 human beings with sharp sticks? We are far more dangerous than they are because we can communicate.

And you know, when they, by the way, I am told that human beings smelled terrible. That that was part of our survival strategy was our body odor was repulsive to animals.

Anyway. Whether that's truth, I return to my original proposition, which is our ability to cooperate is what made us survive.

Kris: Right.

Neill: And without nails and without long teeth, we nevertheless made it out the other end and it's because of our superpower language and cooperation.

Kris: So it sounds

Neill: like my background,

Kris: Neal, you have, you have a really rich background with Fortune 500 companies like Budweiser and Lexus and Toyota.

so you know. [00:04:00] You, you were really in the game working with some big names and using your ability to persuade and tell stories and get people on board with your creative. Is that right?

Neill: That's it. To be a modest, that was my strength, was I wasn't particularly genius, creative person. I was a copywriter and I wasn't better at it than everybody else, but I enjoyed the company of clients and I had one quality that I think was incredibly valuable when it came to persuasion, which was, I was, for the most part, I was a good listener.

So it was rare when I was working at cross purposes with my clients. And as you can imagine, you know, the most important thing about a client is that they pay your bills and the more they enjoy your company and the more they like you and the more they trust you, the more likely they are to pay those bills.

So, um. Yeah, that was my chief asset of in the business, was that I could go into a room of clients and be a good listener and deliver on what [00:05:00] they were hoping for.

Kris: And so after decades of that type of work, what I get a feel from you is that you've gone so deep into this work that it's almost become kind of spiritual to you.

Neill: Well, that's an interesting way of putting that. I will, I will agree with you in this sense that, uh, people operate out of too much fear and too much anxiety, and they needn't, but we are being inundated. By algorithms and forces that incentivize dividing us up and making us afraid. You know, these people are out to get you.

Those ones are stealing from you. You know, they have no right to take your rightful play. You know, I mean, this kind of

Kris: Right.

Neill: This kind of awful, drumbeat of negativity and Yeah. And division. That is the dark side, that's the dark energy of persuasion, that's using repetitive lies and, and, um, you know, pessimism in order to, [00:06:00] you know, rivet people's attention because attention is worth money.

Kris: Right.

Neill: My, the, the light version, the, the version I'm trying to pursue is to persuade people that there is an ROI to kindness and togetherness and cooperation that dwarfs the return on division. Mm. That. When you are good to people and you are a trustworthy person, and instead of going out into the marketplace and saying, what's in it for me?

Rather saying, I think I can help you and I, and even better, I think we can help each other that the, and I'll give you some really solid examples of, of that at work, but I'm preaching that evangel because I'm at the stage in my career when I don't think I'm gonna be, I'm not gonna be starting a new startup, you know, that goes unicorn on anybody.

I just want to leave the commons better than I found it.

And so, if you will, I'm sort of. Vacuuming up around myself right now for all of the sins and mistakes I made in the past to try to increase people's faith that being good to each [00:07:00] other in business is more profitable. I'll give you a couple of really solid examples, and I'll start in a very, uh, what's the word, counterintuitive world of car dealers. And as you can imagine, uh, as all businesses are on a spectrum of, you know, at this end, are the absolute rapacious huns, and then at the other end are sweet people who are only in the business to make life easier for people.

the most profitable and most powerful dealer I ever saw was a guy who was Hallmark, was generosity and trust. And he used to have a kind of unofficial slogan, which was, I'll lose a little money to make a friend. And a good example of how he would do that was he would give his service writers, you know, who were, as soon as you drove in for car service, they would write you up, you know, like, what do you need?

And so forth. And he would say, listen, Jim, if some. Elder gal comes in and she doesn't look like she's made of money and she's in there for anything less. That costs costs less than $200. Just give it to her. Don't charge her and don't tell her it's from me and don't tell her. It's the policy of the store.

We're we'll. Never Stop getting people with their hands out. [00:08:00] Just tell her it's from you because you like her and you know Mrs. Hutchin Curtis, it's nice to see you again. Don't worry about it. That's, that's no charge. Because I want her to drive away thinking I've got a guy in the car business and here's what's going to happen just between you and me and the friends post, she's gonna go home to the tennis club or the bridge club or just her friends and she's never gonna shut up about it.

And so that's already, it has paid for itself in word of mouth. But if she has a son or a daughter, I'm probably gonna sell them 11 cars. So as much as you know, I, I like being sweet to old people. I happen to know we're gonna make a lot of money off this gesture. We can do another thing, which was very clever, which was he, he was doing business near the New Jersey turnpike, and on the turnpike had spring when all of the road salt and all of the debris and everything that they've been putting down to, you know, for traction, that starts to come up and hit people's windshields.

Everybody is driving around on the turnpike with a crack in their windshield.

So what does he do? Every single car that parked in his parking lot, [00:09:00] he would send people out with a little hypodermic needle to put the adhesive in the crack so it wouldn't get any bigger and he wouldn't tell anyone.

He wouldn't, he wouldn't ask permission. He wouldn't charge, and he wouldn't tell anyone. And he said that the logic behind it was he wanted it to be a kind of urban myth. He wanted the word to spread. Like, oh yeah, if you go down there, it'll fix somehow. You're gonna drive out your windshield's fixed. And, and that was, it did what he said it would do, which is it became, people would show up, you know, to, to cheat the system.

They would show up just to get their windshield fixed. They would get fixed and they would drive away. And they're thinking, you know, oh, I cheated the system. No, you didn't, bro, you just increased the, the footprint of this, this myth, which it wasn't a myth at all. Right?

Kris: Right.

Neill: But these, these gestures of kindness and, you know, generosity.

It turned out to be vastly disproportionate in return to his reputation, to the number of reliable and, and, uh, loyal service customers he had to the number of repeat buyers. You know, there, there is a kind of perverse thing about buying a car, which is the dealers actually, [00:10:00] when on a, once the price of a car is well known, they actually don't make that much money off them.

They'll make about 500, $600 off it, but that's not enough to keep the operation running. They really do make their money off repeat purchases and service. And therefore, what you really wanna do is you want to create sufficient trust and graciousness that people come to you for service. Well, a lot of businesses are that way.

They survive on repeat business. And anybody who knows the term cac, customer acquisition cost, CAC, is very expensive. It's very difficult to get your first customer, to get a repeat customer has a CAC of zero. In other words, they've just come back because you've treated them well. So that in principle is the, the preaching I do in the world about business and brands is let's not make it about price, let's make it about you overdelivering in such a way that you are perceived as being generous and sweet, natured trustworthy, and just as loyal to the [00:11:00] customers as they are to you.

And I can, I'll give you a couple other examples. Yeah, yeah.

Kris: These are great.

Neill: So, um, I was at LAX, this was not recent, this was a few years back, but, you know, airports because of the trouble with, uh, the TSA and so on, they were having these insane lines and. People not thinking straight. They often take it out.

They take out their frustration on like the flight attendants or the the desk people, and it's you just, you want to grab them by the lapel and get very close to them and say, it's not their fault. They don't have anything to do with that. Why are you treating them badly? But people are not rational.

Kris: Mm-hmm.

Neill: Well, my friend Marcus and I were down at LAX on one day when Chicago, which was a United hub, LAX is a United hub. So Chicago was having a weather event and all of a sudden there were a lot of delayed and canceled flights in Los Angeles. It's brilliant. Sunshine outside and nobody understands what the hell the problem is.

Kris: Mm-hmm.

Neill: You know what? We're not having any trouble. Well, bro, everything's a connection from Chicago. Marcus was an improv actor and he sees [00:12:00] this, these poor women behind the counter are just getting treated like they have a big switch. They won't flick. You know, why aren't you fixing the weather? So everybody's so irrationally angry with them that you could tell they were just at the, at their wits end with the human race they were finished with.

You know?

Kris: Yeah.

Neill: People suck is basically what they were thinking.

Kris: Mm-hmm.

Neill: The couple just in front of us with this man and woman team, and they were just insufferable, they were awful. They were condescending, they were entitled. Just everything you lament about what we're capable of as a species, especially if they're upper income, you know, they can sometimes really be bad.

Well. The woman is now, she's gone a thousand yard stare. You know, she's been in, she's been in the trenches long enough that she doesn't even mind the shelling anymore. She doesn't care. We get up to the desk, we're gonna check some bags and before she can say anything, or even I can say anything, Marcus just goes, oh man, those two are in big trouble.

And he's pointing at the cup of sleeping. And she goes, what? And he pulls out this little miniature troll doll. I wonder if I have one handy. Um, 'cause I like [00:13:00] to keep, okay, so here's one.

Kris: Oh yeah. So he

Neill: pulls out this little troll doll.

Kris: Yeah.

Neill: And it had hot pink hair. And he says. Bki saw the whole thing, and all the trolls know each other and he's going to tell them what they did.

And if you give him his favorite snack before the sun goes down, he will wreak a horrible revenge. And then he pulls out this like bag of m and ms and he hands them to the woman. And now she doesn't quite know what to make of this lunatic in front of her. But the partner, you know, just to her left goes, can we feed him now?

And so here's what happened, and. The, what Marcus had done. I don't know if he had this in mind or not. He was just being playful. He was just being ridiculous.

Kris: Mm-hmm.

Neill: But the psychological reaction, if you think about it, was, it was profound because what he did was he shocked her enough to where she was no longer even thinking about these two.

Right. There were two of the 11, they, they were no longer on her radar. He had wiped the whiteboard clean, and now all she was thinking about was this lunatic in front of her. But he's a [00:14:00] friendly, lovable lunatic. And is he really like Danish or what the No, no. He's just. Right. Okay. The whole m and ms and everything, and the partner now here, now we know that what happened then was that they opened the bag of m and ms.

They put the troll behind the counter, you know, where nobody else could see it, but they could see it. And you knew that the accumulated m and ms were, the pile was getting bigger and bigger. Whereas with every douche nozzle that came in to be mean to them, they just kept feeding it. And they would laugh.

And, and so behind the counter, there's a kind of perverse pleasure. They're getting out of everybody that treats them bad. They're reacting differently. They're, they're going, oh, that's one more for borque. The revengeful. Okay, so now let's go back to the, the, uh, principle of return on investment. So what was Marcus', ROI?

Well, he, the, the patrol was about 66 cents, and the bag of m and ms was probably at about a buck 20. But when we got to the gate. Most people don't know that. The people at the gate were the same ones taking your luggage down below, and they know [00:15:00] the whole passenger manifest and people don't realize how much discretion those people have to affect your flight.

And guess who got an upgrade? Yeah. Marcus went up to first class, a $472 value for a mini troll and a bag of m and ms. Now, I did not get the upgrade, but I was only too happy to let the universe perform its magic.

Kris: Oh, wow.

Neill: Because, uh, as soon as she said it was the same woman, she goes, uh, she goes, oh, Mr.

McCollum, it looks like you've been upgraded. And then we all looked at each other like he.

So anyway. Oh man, man, that to me, that to me was a very good example of

Kris: Oh, that's,

Neill: that's the karma.

Kris: Yeah.

Neill: The karma of making friends and influencing people, you know, old fashioned Dale Carnegie. I'll give you the, my last example. I have many more, but I'll give you the,

Kris: yeah. Oh, I am Eaton Eze. Yeah, keep going.

Neill: So there is a, uh, there's a standup comedian, oh, [00:16:00] I wish I could remember his name. I'll figure it out. But standup comedian in la he's been doing his thing for years and years. He's kind of a journeyman, he's not a headliner. but he, uh, some years ago he started doing this thing where he would go out on the street in his car and he would roll up next to people and roll down his window, and then he would yell things to them that were very unexpectedly funny.

So, for example, he would pull up next to a woman in her car and he would say, excuse me, do you work for UPS? She goes, no. And he goes, really? 'cause you have the whole package. And then she laughs and then he pulls up next to these two guys on the street and he goes, Hey, would you do me a favor and maybe leave some women for the rest of us?

Okay. And so on. And he would just do this, you know, for two hours a day. And then he would, he would film it and then he would post it on YouTube.

And he got famous for this. And then he wound up getting, get this, oh my god, Kris, from that thing that he would do and he would do it all, you know, all the time.

He got 7 million followers.

Kris: Oh my gosh. [00:17:00]

Neill: And you and I both know that's an income. Yeah. That's like, that's a good income.

Kris: Yeah.

Neill: So all for probably about six or seven hours a week.

Kris: Right. Of fun. Of fun.

Neill: But it's, it's, he enjoys every minute of it. He was doing it just to do it anyway. he loves to make people laugh.

He has goofball things like, do you work for Google? No, really? 'cause you're everything I'm searching for. And then he would pull up next to these women and go, does it ever get tiring being that beautiful? You know, and so on and so on. Just these little things. Now, the reti, the ROI, is so disproportionate to the effort, all because he's just going out into the world trying to make people smile.

Now, even if he encounters the odd duck who feels obnoxious about his, he is so restored by the general feeling.

Kris: Right, right.

Neill: And in business, there was nothing, I don't think there was any. Quite such pleasure to be taken as offering a service or a product that people realize that [00:18:00] it's valuable. Like they, they really like it.

A pair of handmade boots that, you know, you can only get if you wait four months for, or, you know, uh, or I, I used to do a lot of advertising on behalf of Toyota and it was a brand I, to this day, believe in ferociously. Uh, you know, I was a real partisan for the brand. I had the good fortune to be working as an advertiser on a brand I believed in.

Kris: Mm. You

Neill: know, like, how cool is that?

Kris: Yeah.

Neill: But you didn't have to tell a single lie in all of the tell you we're gonna,

Kris: it matters. Yeah.

Neill: Yeah. And I just had such, I always took such pleasure and anybody asked me like, what kind of car they should buy? You were gonna have to shut me up. I could, I would, you know, what kind, what, what do you like to drive?

Do you want a minivan? Do you want a fly? Do you know this? Do you know that Toyota Sienna is absolutely the best minivan? And, uh, do you want a sedan? How about a sporty? And I knew the whole lineup. I knew 18 cars deep, and I could tell you what the grades differences were. And it, it really was like, um, like somebody knocking on your door to preach the gospel.

I mean, I was that obnoxious about it. But the reason I took such [00:19:00] pleasure in it, the reason I was so fanatical was 'cause I could believe in it. I could 100% believe in it.

Kris:

Neill: And yes, they made false steps like a lot of car companies do. Nobody has a perfect record when it comes to, you know, um

right

Neill: repair.

And so, but I did notice that when Toyota finally did have to recall the Camry, it was a very famous recall in 2209. They treated the customer so well and they responded so well to the recall that when they took customer surveys after people were happier with Toyota and their product after the recall than they were before.

Kris: Wow.

Neill: That's who they were. And to me, that's the ROI of kindness and compassion and making something so well and treating people the way they ought to be treated, to the point where, like me, you lock them in for, with a lifetime loyalty that won't tolerate a bad word being spoken about them in your company, and you'll see this again and again when it's small town restaurants and

And, um, you know, non big banks and

Kris: [00:20:00] Right. Yep.

Neill: That you will, you'll notice that there is a, a deep, deep satisfaction had by the people that work there.

Kris: Uh,

Neill: uh, a pride that they don't necessarily have to brag about. They don't go on social media, but they, they wake up in the morning glad that of all the places they could work, at least it's for some place that I enjoy or, you know, I like, you can really, you could truly like your customers.

You can love them, and just by doing your service, you can demonstrate that affection.

Kris: It's, yeah, it's a very different way to approach service. Have you read the book? Unreasonable Hospitality?

Neill: Oh, have I ever? Yeah. Yeah. And, um, there, there's, uh, oh my God, is it, uh oh. What is the name of the author? It's not Danny Meyer.

It's, uh,

Kris: I know, I'm blanking on it right now too.

Neill: Well, he's quite famous for the, for the hotdog thing. Very, yeah.

Kris: Yeah.

Neill: So now what he's a really good example of, and, and Meyer too is how dedicated they are to their own staffs. Like how they're, they at their core belief. It's that if I take care of my people, the people will [00:21:00] take care of the customers that I lead by example as much by what I tell them.

And they're very thorough and they're detail minded, and all that has to happen is for their own staffs to watch them paying attention to the details to realize, oh, he will, he'll change a tablecloth just like anyone else if it's, if he needs to. It's very, very team spirited.

Kris: Mm-hmm.

Neill: There's a, there's a, um, there's a positivity to that can-do, you know, everybody chips in kind of thing.

There's a positivity to it that you can't help but enjoy being around.

Kris: Mm-hmm.

Neill: That, that feeling like, we're all gonna make it. This is going to work, and, you know, we will, whether we are number one at the end of the year or not, I can tell you that we are going to make a run for it because. We, we love what we do to the point where it's not work anymore.

It's, you know, actors work very hard. Mm-hmm. But when they're performing, they don't think of it as work. Do they?

Kris: Mm-hmm.

Neill: Any, any more than Alyssa Lou, when she was winning her gold medal in the Olympics, [00:22:00] her nerves were a very different animal from the nerves of the other competitors.

It just wasn't the same experience.

Kris: Mm-hmm.

Neill: And you could feel it and see it, that when an artist or a musician is performing their art, like a great waiter

Or, or a wonderful mechanic

They are in it, they, they like what they do

Kris: point, it's a, it's a creative expression is what it's, yeah.

Neill: Yeah. In the, in the movie Man On Fire, there's this wonderful line where they say, you know, they're talking about this assassin.

He says, any, anybody can be an artist. If what they do, they do with enough passion, food, what have you. Everybody can be an artist. Well, Cree's Art is death and he's about to paint his masterpiece.

Mm-hmm.

Neill: And it's true of anything. We, if, you know, if you are a stockbroker or you are a, an accountant, there is an art form to it.

I've known enough CFOs to know that there is a lot of art to what they do.

Kris: Oh yeah. I, I'm [00:23:00] actually working with a client right now. Um, I was just working on it before our call. he's a mortgage broker. Yeah. And he is a, a very creative person outside of, of that. He's a guitar player, a musician, but he brings a creativity and, and a masterfulness to that field that.

Is unexpected and really cool. And there's all kinds of, even with story, there's stories are formulaic. fundamentally they're formulaic, but within the formula there, there's limitless creativity that can happen.

Neill: Yeah. Like music. But, uh, yeah, I do have to say that, you know, a mortgage broker in particular, they, their whole orientation is they are trying to make something happen.

They're trying to help you make this happen. So yeah, their creativity is really a, a good component, you know, to, to go back to storytelling for a minute, which is both our sort of, that's our, our purview.

The, the thing that I, the [00:24:00] evangel that I preach when it comes to that is you've got to, the stories you tell reflect who you are more than the way you tell it.

It's what you choose to, to tell, that's where it signals what your priorities are and who you care about and and so forth. And I saw a really good example of this in two different versions of why people should return to office. Now, you know that for a variety of reasons. A lot of CEOs are saying, well, let's get our people back into the office like five days a week.

And after people have experienced work from home and remote work and all of the various and sundry benefits that go to that, they're a little reluctant to give up those rights and privileges, especially since, you know, given that they now eliminated their compute commute, they can actually spend more time working on the, on the projects and so

Kris: forth, right?

Neill: Nevertheless. There are, there are different ways to entice people to come back into the office. And the one of the better versions of that that I saw was from a very avuncular, I love that word, avuncular, which is like, like a pleasant uncle. [00:25:00] a very avuncular, senior executive said, we are, we are returning to the office a, a great number of us.

I'm not going to tell you to come back into the office and I'm not going to disincentivize, you know, your work from home. What I am gonna tell you is something that I is true and that I experienced when I was a lot younger than I am now. When I was early in my career, I got the benefit of having a mentor and it was, when you look at the sweep of my career, it was priceless to get the guidance and counsel of somebody who was watching over me.

Like a father figure and helping me not repeat my mistakes and giving me some of the inside scoop on who the players were. And it was very much like he was a little bit like a drone is now, you know, going forward to tell you what the terrain is going to be like.

Kris: Yeah.

Neill: And I, I will tell you that my mentor had nothing to do with the official reporting schedule.

He was, he was nowhere remotely near my reporting structure. So it was happenstance that this guy took me under his wing [00:26:00] and it benefited me both economically, spiritually, and in terms of my growth as an individual. Now, I can't tell you that I will be your mentor, but I will tell you this, that I am at the stage where, and I see it around on a lot of the senior guys, they just have a compulsion to help younger people.

It's just something that happens to you when you get older. You want to be helpful. To young people because you like young people. And so for better or worse, if you don't come back in the office, you're missing out on an opportunity to get, basically a graduate degree you don't pay for.

Now I heard that and I thought, I'm just paraphrasing.

He actually did a more elegant version of it.

Kris: Yeah.

Neill: But you can see that what he's chosen to do is not make it, you know, a uh, a sanitized, clever way of saying everybody's expected back in the office. You know, or you're gonna get, you know, dis you know, you're gonna get spanked. It was come back in the office, or don't your discretion.

But I will tell you that there are benefits that accrue to those that return, and it was [00:27:00] packaged in such a human way that everybody could see the truth of it. You know, that they go, yeah. You know, I kinda had a feeling, you know, when you're around the boss and you're visible to the boss the next time.

Bonuses happen or the next time layoffs happen, that currency is valuable. You know? Yeah. It's not dollars, but it might as well be, this is what I mean by the story you, the story you tell, what you say, not just how you say it is to me, the more value of the two things. So when you and I are talking about storytelling, I think it becomes really important that people go, alright, what is the appropriate story to tell here?

One of the things, for example, that one of the councils that I gave was to my nephews who were gonna do speeches at a wedding.

Kris: Mm-hmm.

Neill: And. So I did on my, on my website, I did this talk on, you know, giving a good toast and the first thing I said to them was, okay, let's keep in mind what a toast is at a wedding.

A toast is very different at a business dinner [00:28:00] than it is at a wedding. And I want you to understand this right down into the double helix of your DNA. Do you understand me? Now, listen, this wedding is not about you, okay? It's about the young couple. You are not the main character in this play. You're not even the main character in your speech.

You are. You are a supporting cast member whose job is to make the young couple feel good about their decision and as an extra bonus, if you can make the parents feel good because you are the type of friend that they have,

Kris: right?

Neill: They think what an admirable young person. Then you score bonus points.

Because you weren't selfish, you didn't roast anybody. You didn't say anything stupid. You kept your language clean. Then you will have scored a 10 out of 10 by not being the main character. Do you read me the book? Got it. You know, every, every story is based on context. Where am I telling this? Right. What do they want from it?

And unfortunately, you know, I have seen [00:29:00] very, very funny speeches at weddings where it's like, yeah, but it it was about you and you didn't do yourself any favors here because you tell me, does anybody have a right to outshine the bride at a wedding? Answer? No. Don't go there.

Kris: Right, right.

Neill: So, so likewise, in business negotiations. Whether you are trying to encourage people to come back in the office, or you're confronting a very difficult decision about, are we gonna lay off this many people? Or, oh, we are gonna share the pain and stick together. I, you know, I'm gonna make the decision, but I want to hear your ideas.

That's a story.

Kris: Mm-hmm.

Neill: Just that simple gesture is a story. Why? Because I, what the story I'm telling is this is the kind of person I am, and I want to know whether or not this is the right thing to do.

Kris: Mm-hmm.

Neill: I don't know how, what you've experienced in your personal experience, but in my personal experience in small companies that, could either [00:30:00] lay off people or stick together and wind it, you know, and reduce salaries probably seven outta 10 times.

They, they pick cho they choose shared pain.

Kris: Yeah. Yeah.

Neill: And, ironically enough, I think they emerge from that much, much stronger than people that laid them off, you know?

Kris: Oh,

Neill: yeah. When a boss needs, when a boss needs you to stay, when a boss ask, asks you to Yeah. You do something that they, that they stay.

Kris: Yeah. Yeah. I mean, you feel needed. You feel wanted, you feel like, you know, you are, you're, you contribute something to the group that really matters. And yeah.

Neill: That, that ability to make somebody feel as though they matter may be one of the most important skills, uh, of a, of a boss. It was a wonderful case of, uh, Jose Moreno.

He was the, the manager coach of the, oh, geez. They, it was a, a English Premier League soccer team. And, uh, Tottenham Hot Spurs. So he was the manager of the Tottenham team and they were in a game with [00:31:00] Olympiacos and there was just, you know, you know how it is in soccer, like a game can be one nil. Like that's the entire score.

Right?

Kris: Right.

Neill: That's how it could be. So any advantage you have is, is enormous. And what happened was one of the ball boys who was recovering a ball and was giving it to the Tottenham player to send back into play, he caught one of the Olympiacos players napping. He saw that he was distracted for a half second, so he rushed the throw in to the Tottenham player and they beat this guy by two steps.

It led to a very simple score, and it was all because the ball boy was paying attention.

And Marino, who doesn't miss a trick, saw what he'd done. And he comes over and he embraces this kid, and they talked about it in the post game press conference.

Kris: Wow.

Neill: They actually, they, uh, one of the reporters asked him, what was that all about?

And he talks, he sang the praises of this ball boy. And he's, and very seriously, he goes, he was a very good ball boy. He's a very good ball boy. He's not thinking about the scarves in the stands. He's not the there to watch the, the, the spec at the call. [00:32:00] He's playing the game. He's in the game and he winds up inviting him to the, to eat with the players.

Because, because, because Marino understands Everybody matters at one point or another if you're paying attention, even the cleaning crew will save your ass.

And this is a spirit of generosity that makes a great leader. Somebody who acknowledges you matter here. And even on days when you might think you don't keep your eyes peeled and the occasion will rise when you may be the nail in the horse's shoe, that saves this whole battle.

But you know, it's, there's a generosity. Great leaders are actually quite generous in spirit. Let's go back to the, uh, American Revolution. There was a moment at the end of the revolution when George Washington was being suggested as, look, you already have command of the continental Army. You could just pretty much be the strong man.

Like, why don't, why don't we just make you the leader? And Washington gave up his commission, went back to Mount Vernon. [00:33:00] Surrendered his power, and I don't know if this story's apocryphal or not, but apparently George, Richard George, George ii, the English king, heard that this is what happened and proclaimed that man will be remembered as the most important figure of the age F for that gesture.

That the generosity of giving up power as part of the birth of the nation will be remembered as the single most important single act by an individual in the formation of the nation. And and the tradition was after that the peaceful transfer of power was set as the example by George Washington. That's a story.

The story he tells is by his actions out of. Like, who can say these things get gilded? You know, over the hundreds of years, they, they take on a kind of mythic quality that may bear 60% resemblance to the truth. Like, I don't know for a fact that George II ever actually said that, but the important thing was that there's truth in [00:34:00] it,

When you, when you do these things from an, from a, when, when you adopt the car dealer's attitude of, I'll lose a little money to make a friend, in the end, the profit is compound.

Kris: Yeah. Why, why do you think? I feel like, I mean, I've been telling stories and in, in integrating storytelling into my work for a very long time, but it feels like it's really caught on and that people are talking about it now more than ever.

Why do you think that is?

Neill: Well, I. There's a variety of different possibilities. I can't put my finger on it. I'll, I'll suggest, here's one possibility that when you look at a meme stock, a meme stock is 99% story. It, it is defying gravity in the traditional market sense. You know, why is this stock valued like this that is so disproportional to the assets and the, and the revenue?

This [00:35:00] doesn't make sense. No, it doesn't make sense because what has happened is a story has made people irrational.

Now, now they're supporting that stock for reasons that defy logic. So given our fixation with money, I think that the storytelling. Has become the province of the CEO who wants to inflate his stock price by creating a narrative that outpaces the fundamentals.

That's, that's one hypothesis, is that?

Another hypothesis is that when you watch the show Mad Men, the thing that makes Don Draper so powerful is not his, you know, haughty dnce. It's his ability to walk into a room of Kodak executives and tell that carousel story about how this is not a slide projector, this is a time machine, you know, and it's one of the most artful examples of how just the interpretation.

Of how you look at something completely changes its place in your life and the value that, how much you'll pay for it. Mm. Um, and you know, [00:36:00] here's another example of, of how you can just take a simple narrative and all of a sudden it inflates the value of something beyond rationality.

So if you buy an ordinary New York Yankees, baseball jersey on, you know, online with the number three on it, babe Ruth sold number.

It'll cost you probably about in the order of maybe 120, 160 bucks. What if I told you that was the actual jersey worn by Babe Ruth in the 1933 World Series where he called his shot and they beat the Chicago Cubs? How much would you pay for that jersey now? Well now you'd pay literally $24 million

Kris: Uhhuh

Neill: or more.

Kris: Yep.

Neill: It's because of the story attached to it. It's the actual jersey. It was there.

Kris: Right.

Neill: Right. And only one Jersey gets to tell that story.

Kris: Right.

Neill: It's the same as like, well, why would anybody pay? I I can get, get a very, very fine reproduction of the Van Gogh sunflowers painting

By a beautiful frame, beautiful frame for $500.

Or I can literally pay [00:37:00] $180 million if, if I can even get it to go up for sale, I will pay minimum $180 million for it. Why? Why? Because it's the real one. And this is, the thing about a story is you don't just get a painting, you get the entire Van Gogh, uh, legend.

You own a singular asset from an artist whose story is fantastic.

And this is how it is with a lot of things. The, you know, limited supply just means that, that means it's. It is defined by a, you know, like limited supply usually means it's done by an artisan or something like that. Like

There's, there's a fantastic brand of a homemade boot that apparently some guy in Idaho or something makes, and the Germans send him his special leather and whatnot, and it, it takes you four months just to go in there to get your sizes taken.

And then it's gonna take probably about a year and a half to actually get the boots.

But people will pay unbelievable amounts of money for them because of that. All that your, [00:38:00] that lore.

That goes with it.

Kris: Right.

Neill: And so if I think of, let's, let's go to like what a CEO's life is like.

CEO's life is, you know, he has operational considerations and he, he has a very professional people reporting to him, and he has to hold their feet to the fire on reaching certain targets. And he has to be realistic enough about the targets to make sure that they're achievable so that nobody gets burnt out from, you know, just this constant drumbeat of more, more, more.

You know, and on top of that, he has that same, more, more that's in the other ear from investors and, you know, private equity, trying to grind him constantly with pressure about their never enough. There's never enough. You can have the best quarter the company's ever had, and next month if you only do 1% better, uh, you're an idiot.

So a CEO's life very much is about storytelling. It's if it, if you're not practicing the art, you better start getting good at it because you can take. Just the way you answer questions on an earnings call can make you sound confident. And self-assured [00:39:00] and knowledgeable, or it can make you sound prevaricating and tentative and cautious and or incompetent.

And you've got to get in your mind, what is the narrative I'm here to tell today, even if it's bad news. If spun the proper way, it can sound good. Now, bad news is not always bad news. If you look over the long throw of a CEO's tenure, bad news spoken plainly, honestly, with sincerity and you know, cleanly and clearly and not panicking, even if people are upset about the bad news seven months from now, they will remember that you are unafraid to tell them the truth.

That's a story.

And there aren't enough like. That, you know, the CEOs are quite adept at using euphemisms and buzzword buzzwords and, and, uh, cloaking their meaning in sanded terminology. And it, you know, you know the type, it's the, it's the button down collar and then the blue sweater.

You know that that's the Silicon Valley [00:40:00] CEO uniform.

They're casual just like you. Here, let's go have a coffee together. And, and they, they spew this sanitized

Kris: Yeah.

Neill: Chat. GPT press release verbiage.

The best, best q and i i ever saw. Oh, you would've loved it, Kris. It was just, it was a, we did this real song and dance on behalf of a very, very large client.

We were trying to win their business for a multimillion dollar installation.

The president of the company was whip smart and, and very. He was very, uh, affable. But we, after doing this big, colorful, loud, brilliant dog and pony show, he was skeptical that we could get everything done by the deadline.

That was, was hard. It was a hard deadline.

You could not violate this timetable. So he wanted to know if I'm gonna do apples to apples against the other people whose ideas I've seen. I need to know how much of this I'm comparing. And our, our chief of operations, the guy who was in charge of building the whole stuff, you know, everything.

He hadn't said a word [00:41:00] the entire meeting. We all had these little microphones in front of us 'cause it was a big panel. And finally the president says he, he turns to this guy and he says, how much of what they've shown me today, can you actually finish by opening day? And without a beat? This guy just leans into the microphone and goes a hundred percent.

Like that. And so that was, that was not two words. That was one word. A hundred percent. A hundred is spelled 18. All lowercase, right? A hundred percent. Now that was, that was the official response, but here's what the text actually reads. It's like, brother, I wouldn't let them show you anything I couldn't build.

They may be the ones talking, but believe it when I tell you I'm in charge here. Nobody makes a move unless I say it's okay, because I'm the one who has to answer for it in the end, and I have seen these things come to [00:42:00] grief and I will not live through that again.

Like it said all that.

in that one answer.

Now, why did it say all that? Because he didn't hesitate. He didn't prevaricate. It wasn't sanded. There was no disclaimer. It was 100% belief from somebody who was going to have to live with that. Mm-hmm. That promise.

Kris: Right.

Neill: And the, so he told a story in one word.

And the reason it's so echoes in my memory Yeah.

Is because, is because it's so rare to hear an answer like that.

Kris: Yeah. Yeah. And you don't question it, right. It's just, it's got the weight of the truth.

Neill: Whatcha say? Are you sure?

Kris: Yeah.

Neill: What do you mean? Am I sure? By the way, that guy who gave that answer, he was, he was a former underwater welder, so this guy was a no-nonsense

Kris: under pressure.

Neill: Yeah,

Kris: yeah, yeah.

Neill: Like, you know, I risked my life doing this job kind of a guy. Yeah. So, yeah, he was, he was a serious home brain.

Kris: Oh my gosh. You are [00:43:00] full of so much wisdom. A lot of the people listening to us today are coaches, consultants, solopreneurs, they're great at what they do. They're, they have a heart to help their clients.

I'm curious, what kind of wisdom or guidance can you share from all your experience around storytelling business? Yeah. You name it. Any direction you wanna go? Well,

Neill: yeah, I'll stick to storytelling. So here is the, here is the one thing that most people underestimate, and if you do this properly, the dividends are abundant.

most people do not rehearse enough when they're gonna make a sales pitch or they're gonna make a presentation, or they're gonna be on a panel discussion. They do not prepare adequately. And when you are really. I'll give you an example. If I'm going to tell a two minute story, I will rehearse that dozens, literally dozens of times.

I will do it over and over and over into a camera so that I can watch myself back on how it sounds.

And [00:44:00] generally speaking, it'll take me about 31 takes to get facile with it. So like, I know the, I know the rhythmic sweep of it. It doesn't mean I've memorized it.

Kris: Right.

Neill: But I've got, but I know, I know how to say

Kris: this.

You're, you, you're fluent with it, but

Neill: yeah. Yeah,

Kris: yeah. Okay. Yeah.

Neill: I, I know the rhythm of it and I'll, I'll feel good telling it, but most people will not sit still and do it 30 times in a row. They just won't. The great actors will

The great actors, that's just part of their process and they don't shy away from it.

And they don't, they don't think of it as work. They think it's the process. This is the process. I wanna give the best possible performance I can, which means I really need to know these lines. I need to know these lines so deeply. It is as if I have made them up myself. I, you need to feel it so completely that you saying it seems like it's the first time it's ever been said, and most people, because they're busy, you know, CEOs especially are very, very busy.

But here's the dividend. When you go in there and you nail it, I mean, when you really, when it sounds great, that adds [00:45:00] 30%, 30 IQ points to your, to the way people perceive you.

Kris: Right?

Neill: They, they think you are brilliant because you had it, it just seemed to roll out of you so smoothly. Oh my god. You know, Ron is brilliant.

Did you see him do that panel discussion? Remember when they asked him, you know, that question and it was just the most, yeah, he rehearsed it 35 times. He was prepared. To do the rehearsal. And then on top of that, most people don't, they, they know roughly what they're gonna say as opposed to writing down exactly what they intend to say.

So that their, their choice of vocabulary is just what they want it to be.

They look for the right, they look for, you know, instead of saying it was colorful, they'll say it was vibrant. Or they'll say, they'll say, well, I hadn't thought I couldn't remember up to now, but the vividness of your description has restored him to my memory.

You know, they, they have the, the right words for it that make them seem intelligent.

Kris: Yeah.

Neill: And so rehearsal is, it is not a nice to have, it's a must have if you want to be [00:46:00] competitive in terms of the way you're perceived. about the way you present things. Then another thing that people underestimate is they really should use their phones to record themselves making presentations and watch them back.

And I know most people, most, most, most people are really uncomfortable with watching themselves on camera. Mm-hmm. They cringe when they watch it.

But, and this is what I teach all my people. You've got to get over that. Get over it.

Watch yourself anyway. And don't, Nope. Don't stop watching. As soon as it makes you uncomfortable, watch the whole thing.

I wanna see you because you need to know how you're coming off.

Kris: Right.

Neill: You need to, you need to tune yourself up. You need to get better. This is like throwing a baseball around. You gotta, you gotta keep throwing. You gotta practice your backhand, man. You gotta practice and you gotta watch yourself on camera.

Doing a backhand and then you go, oh, is that what I look like? Oh God. So it, we are gifted with this device. It gives you the ability very simply to record yourself doing it and then watch it back. And there's another dividend to rehearsing on [00:47:00] camera. And here it is. And it's not insignificant. When you get used to recording yourself on camera, you get good on camera, you get good on camera.

That's fantastic. As you would know, right?

Kris: Yeah,

Neill: yeah. Video.

Kris: I can relate to that. Yeah.

Neill: Video is the canvas that we, that we practice our art on now. Right. That it, it is. If you can get good on video and you can do good presentations on video, you can prerecord your presentations.

And all they have to do is they don't even have to cut to you.

They just go, let's play, let's play Kris's thing. And it's, it's letter. Perfect. Of course it is. But you know, everybody's got a personal brand and you know, you're, all of us have a variety spectrum of skills. Some people are super organized, some people have incredibly high energy and some people are really, really good on camera.

And that being good on camera man, it's 2026. There is always a place for that. There's a, you know, the one of the jobs that I used to do years ago was a job nobody else [00:48:00] wanted to do, but I loved it. It was, Toyota has a very, very large dealer network across the country and somebody had to go out and interact with all the dealers to present them with the campaigns and ask them for their, their money on certain campaigns, you know, you had to go out and you interact with board boards of dealers and these are hard charging.

Entrepreneurs who are quite unaccustomed to having to listen to nonsense. And were very, very quick decision makers, and they're a tough audience. Mm-hmm. They're, you know, they're deeply suspicious.

And they don't, they don't want some flashy ad guy to come in there and think they're gonna bamboozle them.

It's like, bro, do you know who you're talking to? We're professionals here. You're not gonna trick anybody.

Kris: Right.

Neill: That was a great lesson is so you don't try, don't even, you don't even try. But through that crucible, it does teach you that being sincere and authentic is your best weapon in a tough room.

And, and, but rehearsal is the way to get there. There's a, isn't this, it's paradoxical. The [00:49:00] more you prepare, the less rehearsed you look

Kris: right,

Neill: the more authentic you actually become, because now you're. You know what you're gonna say now, so you're comfortable being yourself again. You know, you're not, you're not worried about what to do with your hands and stuff.

Kris: Totally. Yeah. It's like within, within the delivery, you, you can be a little bit nuanced and creative and play a little bit within it, right?

Neill: Yeah, yeah.

Kris: You're

Neill: gonna enjoy it.

Kris: Yeah. You

Neill: enjoy it. So if you, if we go back to like the wedding toast. Now, remember, it's not about you. It's about these two young people who are making a big step here.

And you need to reassure them that they're doing the right thing,

Kris: right?

Neill: And always remember they are the stars of the show. So your job is to be supportive and reassuring and so forth. Now, nobody really cares how good a presenter you are, how good a speaker you are. All they care about is what's in your heart.

Kris: But

Neill: then again, that is all the more reason why you should rehears. [00:50:00] Because only when you truly get comfortable with it, as you were saying it was play. Mm-hmm. But this is also, it's your heart coming out.

Because you're comfortable enough to, that escapes instead of your nerves.

So that was the one thing I wanna leave your people with is they are un no matter who it is, I'm, trust me, they are underestimating how much time they need to spend getting ready for a public appearance.

Kris: Mm. Thank you. That, that, that really is good for me to hear as well. How do you work with your clients?

Neill: in a variety of different ways. So I'll, I'll do, um, I'll do one-on-one coaching, although that's, you know, you can't scale. It gets very time consuming and so forth.

then I'll do small group sessions.

I, I do have to say I really, really love one-on-one coaching. I, it's, it's fun to try to help people. They're very, very specific needs.

Like somebody's trying to overcome an accent, or somebody's got huge stage fright or

Or somebody's not, they're not sure how they can even apply a story and so on.

I love doing that, but I, I do find that small groups, you know, eight people and so forth, it's, it's fun [00:51:00] to do that. I just did, a coaching clinic with, uh, a high school in Minneapolis who are trying to send out the right marketing messages, you know, to their, they've got a variety of different constituents.

I mean, obviously the students, but obviously the students' parents, and then also obviously the people that they have to fundraise with. And then obviously the cl you know, the, um, the staff and the

Kris: right,

Neill: you know, well, in each of those cases, what, what you're trying to do is just stay, uh, on your most fundamental values that make you special, and it was great fun to watch them arrive at what they believed those were.

It was a, it was such a pleasure to watch people who were thinking that, you know, this is about public relations and this is about, you know, word choices and so forth. When it was, no, in the end, it's really about what do you believe, what do you believe is important?

If you could only do one thing for your students, what would you hope it would be?

And you would hear just the most marvelous answers. You know, the thing that was most encouraging about that experience was how, how [00:52:00] in line and co uh, not coherent,

Kris: congruent,

Neill: you know, just how congruent the faculty was with the leadership.

Like how everybody really did agree in the end.

About what made them who they were.

And I thought, I left that experience going, wow, the young people that come out of this institution are going to lead, um, fulfilling lives. Because they were all about lives of public service. That was what the institution was for. So we want to train young people to live lives of service, to be compassionate and generous and ethical, and even in competitive situations, be honorable and, you know, have the strength of your convictions.

And it reminded me of all of the better clients I'd had. It, Remi, they, they, you know, if you, I wish everybody could have been there in the room with me, like everybody, because you would have such hope for the future.

You and I both know, and we were talking about this before you started [00:53:00] recording, you and I both understand that algorithms and, and media is being incentivized to divide us and to keep us paranoid and fearful.

And they, you know, pummel us with negativity. If you can just get away from it for a while. And meet with other people, even people that you possibly disagree with vehemently about something, if you spend enough time with them away from the influence of media

Everybody kind of winds up, you know, the, the waves start to calm

Kris: And everything goes back to smooth. And if you were in that room, you would see people who were, who recognized that the impact of negativity and, and media bias and so on, you know, was having on them and they were determined to be the antidote

Neill: To that they were sending young people out in the world to be the antidote to the division and negativity.

And um, you know, it's very, it's very hard to, it's very hard to face the day unless you go out and seek out [00:54:00] chances to restore your soul like that.

I think that's why time outdoors is so powerful.

Kris: You

Neill: know, the outdoors tends to, it, it casts sunlight on what is otherwise like a vibrating enclosure.

Kris: Mm. Where, where can we find you, Neal? I, I know everyone listening is gonna wanna follow you and be connected with you and Yeah. So where do we go?

Neill: So, I'm easy to find if you just know how to spell my name, because I'm the only one in the world who spells my name. N-E-A-L-F-O-A-R-D. And because of that, if you Google me, you'll find me and you'll find me on Instagram and TikTok and YouTube and, and everywhere else.

But the place I'd really like people to visit is. Story fire.net. So www sometimes you have to put that in www.storyfire.net. It gets its name from us telling stories around the campfire. So story fire.net. And how much? I wish I had the.com, but I don't, they're holding it. Ransom the bastards. Um, [00:55:00] so story fire.net and, and the the cool thing is that people go and they visit that site.

I have quite a number of videos if you wanna explore the course that I sell there. there are quite a few videos that they can get a sample of sort of what's, what's on offer.

Kris: That's great. What a gift, what a gift to be with you today. And I'm just yeah. Delighted to know you back. Yeah,

Neill: likewise.

Kris: All right.

Thank you.

Is your website turning away Potential clients? I can help you turn that around. Book a moneymaking messaging call with me today and we'll transform your story into your most powerful sales tool. That's all for this episode of From Click to Client. Don't forget to subscribe and follow. I'm Kris Jones and I'll see you next.

Get the 5 StoryBrand Soundbites That Will Attract More Clients

Privacy Policy: Your Information is 100% Secure

Clarity That Increases Conversions

Put Them Everywhere Immediately

Only Takes 10 Minutes